Are Conservatives funny?
And I don’t mean in a “Ha, ha! Look at that wacky Conservative!” kind of way. I mean in a creative make-me-laugh with your stinging satire kind of way.
This is what I thought about watching the decidedly unfunny An American Carol trailer, which advertises the latest film from ZAZ vet David Zucker, himself (along with many of the leads) a Conservative.
Well, that answers your question right there. Airplane! is one of the funniest films of all time, and Zucker, to the best of my knowledge, was not a hippie when he wrote and directed it with Jim Abrahams and Jerry Zucker.
At the same time, what makes this film stand out is that it’s one of the few comedies to poke fun at liberals. So maybe the better questions are; is making fun of liberals funny, and if so, why is it so rare outside of talk radio?
The answer to the first part is a resounding yes, as Trey Parker and Matt Stone have demonstrated time and again on South Park. Their “Smug Alert!” ep is still one of the best. Not to mention the beating Hollywood liberals take in Team America: World Police. Part of what makes their humor work is that instead of calling for a dedication to the left or the right, they generally call for reason, skewering any position that defies it.
And to explain the scarcity, yes, Hollywood is disproportionately staffed by the left-leaning. There are many arguments to made as to why, not the least of which is artistic endeavors self-selecting for the liberal-minded. But a more fundamental hurdle is the fact that the words “conservative” and “humor” generally don’t run together, since humor, for the most part, involves making fun of order. And conservatives - the very word “conservative” - connote preserving the established order.
The Marx Brothers didn’t get their chuckles telling the rich and powerful they were doing just fine.
Now, certainly there are many rich and powerful liberals, and here’s where conservative humor stands a shot, but that still doesn’t explain why Zucker’s trailer just doesn’t look funny.
I think there’s a far simpler explanation. Basically, the last truly great comedy he directed was The Naked Gun. The trailer for An American Carol reminds me of the latter days of Zucker’s career, the Scary Movies 3 and 4, and their unfortunate progeny, the Epic Date Disaster Superhero Meet the Spartans Movies.
And no matter what your political affiliation, those just aren’t funny.